Two rules

A comparison of rules, not of results. The book studies history. This site does not promise that one method beats the other.
Fixed buyingValue averaging
Fixed in advanceThe contribution. It can grow over time.The account value at each step
What the trade depends onThe calendar onlyThe gap between the month’s target and what the shares are worth now
SalesThe rule itself does not sellAbove the line, it sells. You can skip that
In the bookChapter 4, pp. 83–85Chapter 5, pp. 97–99

How the fixed contribution is found

Shares you already hold are valued at the horizon as if they grew at the expected return. Whatever is still missing from the goal has to come from contributions. The first contribution is solved so that the series — each one a bit larger if you allowed growth — exactly covers that gap.

The future value of the series is the first contribution times ((1 + return) to the power of the months, minus (1 + growth) to the same power), divided by the difference between return and growth. If return and growth are equal, that writing would divide by zero. The limit is used instead.

How the value line is found

A month’s planned contribution is the cash that reaches the next point if the holding earned exactly the expected return. If the market did something else, the trade is different. The gap stays in the reserve. The line itself is described on its own page: the target bends, it does not rise in a straight step.

What this site does not do

It does not say “buy this fund”, and it does not score which method would have won on past prices. The tickers in the form are examples, so there is a price to type. One random index path from chapter 7 sits on the calculator and on the book page: it is about how wide returns can be, not about picking a security.

The calculator chart shows money per month, not the account value. The solid black line is the planned contribution, the orange dash is the fixed contribution, and the blue line with diamonds is the trade in the price picture you picked.

Calculate both paths